An Ode to Tater Salad
Posted by Sunday on Aug 5, 2009 at 8:31 pm in Food RantRight, so, this has got to be a quick one because I’m a hair busy.
Potato salad. Everyone has a recipe. I don’t like most of them. It’s terrible, I know, but they’re always just wrong somehow. I think, like pasta salad, they tend to just be nothing but potatoes and some sauce (mayonnaise, generally) and little else. Eggs, which doesn’t help pull the entire thing out of the white hole of blandness it is falling into.

And so also like pasta salad, my solution is to up the “other stuff” quotient as much as I dare. Lots of celery, red onion thinly sliced and green onions. As many frozen peas as I can push without it turning into pea salad. Bacon. Enough fresh dill that there’s a real danger of permanently stinking up the fridge.

And last but not least, making the dressing from about 2/3 sour cream to 1/3 mayonnaise. After that a healthy dose of salt, pepper, a spoonful of sugar and a big glug of rice vinegar and now, folks, we’re talking.

It’s perfect, and I can and did eat it every day for about five days. It could even have withstood more herbs; basil never hurt anyone, and rosemary never met a potato it didn’t like. Even more vinegar, but I wanted other people to be able to eat the salad too. In fact, I’m not even going to list a recipe, because it’s one of those things: you’ve already got a potato salad you like. And that’s just grand.
August 5th, 2009 | Food Rant
That’s wrong. That last thing you said? Not true. I don’t like potato salad at all. Never met one that I loved. Oh I’ll eat it if it’s placed in front of me, but really, that’s true for most everything.
Well, sure. But I think you like mashed potatoes, right? If so, what do you think the difference is?
1) mashed
2) warm
3) butter
=what the difference is
Here, here! I most heartily approve of a high “other stuff” ratio in any salad (tuna, chicken, tater…). For dressing a potato salad, I will usually add plain yogurt and mustard for tanginess and a lower oil quotient. And a buttload of black pepper. Maybe some pickles, but not always.